I wrestled with the same issue. Cox communications out here has 9 HDTV channels but their prices are absolutely ridiculous, so I stuck with Directv. Directv is offering installation for three receivers including a DVR right now if you are interested.

My parents live in KC and they didn't have issues with reception unless the storm was extremely violent and windy. They now use time warner cable for convenience, but I would say the cable goes out just as periodically as the dish; once or twice a year.

If prices were the same, I would have Digital Cable for conveinence of upgrading, but they aren't, so I have Directv. Hey, I'm an Outlaw, aren't we supposed to be value conscious? Also, Directv has NFL Sunday Ticket, which being a KC native, that was really important also.