Beatles Box Set (Stereo or Mono)?

Posted by: edcrash1

Beatles Box Set (Stereo or Mono)? - 09/21/09 07:13 PM

I am not sure whether this is the correct location to post this, but I wanted to get thoughts from the Outlaws about their preference (and why) for the Beatles Box Set in Stereo or Mono (or both). I have ordered the Stereo Set, but have not yet received it so I am curious what others on here have to say given that I trust the opinions here much more than on Amazon (where I purchased the stereo set).
Posted by: fdxsteve

Re: Beatles Box Set (Stereo or Mono)? - 09/21/09 09:29 PM

I recently purchased the separate cd's rather than backordering the box set. I bought the stereo version because that's the way I remember them sounding when they were originally released. We only had mono radios back then but my parents had one of the first stereo record players when they came out. So when the fake stereo versions came out we bought them and they sounded pretty good. Much better than the mono versions. The new cd's sound sweet.I listen in stereo mode not surround sound. They still retain the channel separation between instruments and vocals and which artist is singing. I actually turn my head on some passages and this to me is nice. If your interested, the cd version of Harry Belafonte at Carnegie Hall is great. It was taped in 1958 I believe using mics. set up on the stage. The opening intro with the audience clapping had my father quickly turning off the sound because we had never heard applause coming from around us and he thought the sound was some kind of feed back. Anyhow, The Beatles sound good in stereo. If you want you can play them in mono on your sys.
Posted by: AusTexRocker

Re: Beatles Box Set (Stereo or Mono)? - 09/22/09 02:39 PM

I agree with fdxsteve on getting the stereo set. I also purchased discs separately rather than the box set. The vocals in one channel and instruments in the other was a little unusual to me as I listened to Rubber Soul. The Beatles (White Album) sounds incredible. Even after 40 years of listening to this work, I was hearing things for the first time...great fun.