Originally posted by bkirby:
In general, a coax is a much sturdier connection thus producing far less jitter in the signal. Digital jitter can result in image smearing and other strange anomolies in the sound presentation. If you have the means, I would reccomend using a coax connection over optical with any electronic equipment!!!
The connection has little to do with jitter. Jitter is the result of a distorted waveform, and since the waveform for a digital signal is only 1 or 0, even a moderately distorted signal is going to be read correctly. To achieve jitter requires massive amounts of signal distortion, and the effects (like loss of dynamic range, clicking, or random phantom tones) are anything but subtle. If you encounter these it's going to be a defective cable, and not an inherent weakness in the type of cable.
Coax and optical cables are used for digital signals for precisely this reason - they are highly resistant (optical is immune) to EFI/RFI. If anyone can point to an A/B comparison that shows a quantifiable difference, I'd be surprised.